Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Military Space News .




Subscribe to our free daily newsletters



Outside View: Preparing Iraq's Army

an unstainable deployment

Washington DC (UPI) Aug 05, 2005
A detailed analysis of the current Multi National Force-I and Multi-National Security Training Command-I effort to train and equip Iraqi forces indicates that this effort has been comprehensively reorganized over the course of the last year and that it now includes far better readiness standards and significant allied contributions.

The two main issues to be addressed are providing the full range of civilian advisers needed to supplement the military in training the police forces and how Iraqi forces should acquire armor and other heavier weaponry over time.

Progress in unit generation is necessarily much slower than progress in creating trained and equipped individuals.

According to some press reports, the Iraqi Army had a total of 81 operating combat battalions by late May 2005, but a new evaluation matrix developed by MNF-I rated only three of those battalions at the top level of readiness and capability.

At the top level of readiness, a unit is capable of independent operations without coalition support.

Only one of 26 brigade headquarters had such a rating. However, many other combat battalions were still contributing to the fight, either with some support provided by coalition forces (the second level of readiness) or fighting alongside coalition forces (the third level).

If one included all of the special police battalions, the press reported that the total force had risen from 81 battalions to 101, but the number of battalions rated in the top category of mission capability only rose from three to five.

Although the other operating combat battalions were contributing to the counter-insurgency to varying degrees, MNF-I concluded that it needed to make further major increases in the number of U.S. advisory or "transition teams" embedded in Iraqi units and was seeking to deploy rapidly 2,500 more soldiers by mid-June.

Coalition leaders are concerned that detailed reports on the ranking of Iraqi forces will be used by insurgents to focus attacks on weaker units, but coalition experts summarized the status of Iraqi forces in mid-June as follows:

No special police units and less than a handful of army units were rated "fully capable" of independent counter-insurgency operations. Some 40 percent of the special police units and 20 percent of army units were rated capable of leading operations with coalition support.

Some 40 percent of the special police units and 45 percent of army units were rated capable of conducting counter-insurgency operations when "fighting alongside" coalition units. Less than 10 percent of the special police units and 20 percent of army units were rated as "forming" or incapable of conducting counter-insurgency operations.

Put differently, more than 60 Iraqi army combat battalions could then perform a counter-insurgency role when operating with coalition forces; more than 20 combat battalions were capable of counter-insurgency operations, but needed some specific coalition support to do so. In the case of special police forces -- which included the Public Order Brigades, the Mechanized Police Brigade and the Special Police Commando Brigades, there were roughly 27 battalions authorized and 14 actually operational, all of them either fighting alongside or with coalition support. A long way from a perfect force, but a vast improvement over a single active battalion in July 2004.

Looking towards the future, the focus of Iraqi and MNF efforts has clearly shifted from force formation to force effectiveness, and the MNSTC-I goal is to "graduate" most remaining units from basic/small unit training at Level 3 ( fighting alongside coalition forces). Their progression to Level 2 or Level 1 will follow on varying timelines. Some "graduated" units may still be assessed as Level 4 (forming), but they should be the exception.

Are Iraqi troops being deployed before they are ready in an attempt to demonstrate progress? This may have been the case through the spring of 2004. It no longer seems to be an issue. As is noted above, far better readiness and training standards are being applied.

Should there be a more gradual training schedule to allow Iraqi units to develop greater cohesion and capabilities before exposing them to hostilities?

Iraqi forces are deployed into more-demanding missions only on the basis of their actual performance, as reflected by their transition readiness assessment. The coalition transition teams that guide them through their initial training and equipping remain with them as they transition to operational status and as they are slowly introduced to more demanding missions over time.

Keeping them in training status would make things worse, not better. Their involvement in appropriate operations will give them needed experience and ensure that leaders and other ranks are competent and active while they build practical cohesion and capability.

Should the number of Iraqi security forces be increased by integrating the Badr brigade (an anti-Saddam Shia militia group), the Peshmurga (Kurdish forces), or other local militias into the Iraqi army or National Guard? Would the political ramifications of such integration outweigh the security benefits?

The problem lies in the word "integration." If it means properly vetted, fully trained, and dispersed as individuals into a wide range of units to create truly national forces, the answer is yes. In the real world, Iraqi forces have been recruiting militia members as individuals for almost a year as part of the Transition and Reintegration of Militias program.

Success in these endeavors has been mixed. Total dissolution of militias will take time and serious negotiations and will probably be successful only when the political parties see the militias as no longer required because the central government is providing adequate security.

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

Related Links
SpaceDaily
Search SpaceDaily
Subscribe To SpaceDaily Express

Outside View: U.S. Options In Iraq
Washington DC (UPI) Aug 05, 2005
The key issues affecting U.S. strategy in Iraq are not military, but politics, governance, aid and economics. The United States and the Iraqi government have largely "cast the die" in military terms, and the issue is not one of strategy as much as finding ways to ensure that the development of Iraqi forces will actually succeed.







  • Analysis: Indo-U.S. Ties Not To Hurt China
  • US-Indian Military Accord Does Not Compromise Security: Defence Minister
  • US Deputy Secretary Of State Zoellick In China For Strategic Dialogue
  • US Plans To Put An Indian Astronomer In Orbit

  • Commentary: Iran On Points?
  • One Killed, One Hurt In Fire On Scrapped Russian Nuclear Submarine
  • Marathon North Korean Nuclear Talks Struggle Through Seventh Day
  • Defiant Iran Prepares To Resume Nuclear Work

  • NGC-Led Team Selects ATK's Utah Facility For Stage 1 Motor Work On KEIs
  • Surrounded By Hostile Missiles
  • US Prepares For New Round Of Civil Aviation Missile Defense Tests
  • India Tests Short-Range Surface-To-Air Missile

  • SBX Radar Takes Giant Stride Forward
  • BMD Focus: The Test Of Reality
  • Missile Politics On The Northern Flank
  • Japan To Bring Forward Missile Defense Shield To 2006: Report

  • Air France Plane Hit By Lightning Before Crash: Passengers
  • Rolls-Royce Shares Rocket On Strong Profits, Dividend News
  • Imaging Technique Reduces Structural Component Failures
  • Rockwell Collins Applies New NASA Software Verification Technology

  • European Defence Agency Briefs Industry On Long-Endurance UAV Needs
  • Boeing Awards Multiple Contracts for First Phase of New UAV Program
  • RQ-8B Fire Scout Vertical Takeoff and Landing Tactical UAV System
  • Japan Plans First Spy Plane To Watch North Korea: Report

  • Outside View: Preparing Iraq's Army
  • Outside View: U.S. Options In Iraq
  • Politics & Policies: Bush Has A Strategy
  • US Probes Insurgency Funding

  • US Marine Corps Orders Advanced Gunnery & Virtual Convoy Training Systems
  • Outside View: UXBs At Closing US Bases
  • Training, Hydration Help Baghdad Troops Cope With Heat
  • Raytheon Delivers First Increment Of Microlight Radios For Land Warrior

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement