Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Military Space News .




Subscribe to our free daily newsletters



Puffing On Iraq

According to a story in the Sept. 13 Oregonian, "The U.S. military did not count people killed by bombs, mortars, rockets or other mass attacks--including suicide bombings--when it reported a dramatic drop in the number of killings in the Baghdad area last month, the U.S. Command said Monday...." Photo courtesy of AFP.
by William S. Lind
UPI Commentator
Washington (UPI) Sep 25, 2006
During World War II, one of Hitler's favorite sayings was, "All generals lie." Today, Washington prefers the word "spin" to lie, although the difference is often difficult to parse. As an 18th century man, I prefer an 18th century word: puffery. If we consider some of the statements coming from our military leaders regarding the war in Iraq, we might think they are all clones of General Puff.

In recent days, a classified report on the situation in Anbar province, written by a senior Marine intelligence official in Iraq, has been widely reported on in the press. The report, which I have not seen, apparently paints a bleak picture of the situation there. According to a story by Tom Ricks of the Washington Post, the Marine commander in Anbar, Maj. Gen. Richard Zilmer, said "I have seen that report and I do concur with that assessment." Score one for the Marine Corps in the honesty department.

But then, General Puff seems to have stolen Gen. Zilmer's identity. According to Ricks' story,

"Zilmer also insisted that "tremendous progress" is being made in that part of the country....

"'I think we are winning this war,' he told reporters. "We are certainly accomplishing our mission...."

"The 30,000 U.S. and allied troops are 'stifling' the enemy in the province, Zilmer told reporters. But he wouldn't say the insurgents are being defeated."

Puffery, you see, tries to avoid statements that might later be checked against facts. By puffing out nice-sounding words such as "stifling," it seeks to create an impression that is favorable but too nebulous to hold to account.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer reported a wonderful piece of military puffery on Sept. 7. Speaking of a supposed turnover of command of the Iraqi armed forces to Iraq's government, U.S. Maj. Gen. William Cladwell said, "This is such a huge, significant event that's about to occur tomorrow. If you go back and map out significant events that have occurred in this government's formation in taking control of the country, tomorrow is gigantic."

In reality, the Iraqi government took control of just a single division; most troops in the Iraqi Army take their orders from militia leaders, not the government; and the Iraqi government itself takes its orders from the United States. This "huge, significant event" changed nothing.

According to a story in the Sept. 13 Oregonian, "The U.S. military did not count people killed by bombs, mortars, rockets or other mass attacks--including suicide bombings--when it reported a dramatic drop in the number of killings in the Baghdad area last month, the U.S. Command said Monday...."

"That led to confusion after Iraqi Health Ministry figures showed that 1,536 people died violently in and around Baghdad in August, nearly the same number as in July.

"The figures raise serious questions about the success of the security operation launched by the U.S.-led coalition. When they released the murder rate figures, U.S. officials and their Iraqi counterparts were eager to show progress in restoring security in Baghdad."

Sufficiently eager, it seems, to puff the numbers.

We expect puffery from politicians. But when General Puff represents the military to the American people, the military puts itself in a dangerous situation. The loss of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan will, at some point, have domestic political repercussions, perhaps of some magnitude. The U.S. military will rightly bear some of the blame for both failures. It cannot credibly claim that it was forced to fight two Fourth Generation wars with Second Generation tactics and doctrine, when it has rebuffed every effort to move beyond the Second Generation -- The U.S. Marine Corps is a partial exception.

But the American people, I think, will be more forgiving of mistakes than of puffery, which in the end is a deliberate attempt to deceive. If the public comes to think that all generals lie, the American armed services may find it difficult to re-establish their good reputations.

(William S. Lind, expressing his own personal opinion, is Director for the Center for Cultural Conservatism for the Free Congress Foundation.)

Source: United Press International

Related Links
Follow the first techonology war of the 21st century at SpaceWar.com

Thomas Hobbes Was Right Anarchy Does Not Work
Washington (UPI) Sep 22, 2006
The latest U.N. report on conditions in Iraq confirmed the wisdom of the 17th century British political philosopher Thomas Hobbes. Hobbes, a survivor of the bloody English civil wars of the 1640s, famously concluded that in the absence of any effective government, the life of human beings became "nasty, brutish and short." That, Hobbes concluded, was why even rule by a harsh tyranny was preferably to the chaos of struggling for survival under no government at all.







  • Mideast Woes Alarm Growing Number Of US Foreign Policy Analysts
  • Should Russia Claim Great Power Status
  • China Urges Abe To Properly Handle History
  • China Supports Establishment Of Effective Global Partnership

  • Armitage Expects North Korean Nuclear Test Before Year-End
  • Iran Warns It Can Finish Nuclear Plant Without Russia
  • North Korea Losing Ground Militarily Says US Pacific Commander
  • Iran Warns Of Lightning Response To Any Attack

  • BAE Systems Inertial Measurement Unit Selected For New Air-to-air Missile
  • South Korea Develops Cruise Missile
  • Norway Fires Its First Raytheon-Built Evolved SeaSparrow Missile
  • Australia Signs Contract For JASSM Follow On Standoff Weapon

  • A Dream Month For Ballistic Missile Defense
  • US Navy Certifies Latest Version Of Aegis Missile Defense System
  • Raytheon-SAIC Team Selected For NATO Theater BMD Work
  • TEAMSAIC Selected For NATO Active Layered Theater BMD Support Contract

  • European Aerospace Industry Set To Enter Russia
  • L-3 AVISYS Extends Its Civil Aircraft Self-Protection Systems Offerings
  • Fiber Optics Poised to Reach New Heights On Airplanes
  • Boeing, Chinese Carriers Finalize Orders for Next-Generation 737s

  • Andaman Seeks Drones For Surveillance Of Tropical Archipelago
  • UAV Catches Anti-Iraqi Forces Mortar Team
  • Scientists Test Unmanned Aerial Systems Refueling
  • Reaper Moniker Given To MQ-9 Unmanned Aerial Vehicle

  • Puffing On Iraq
  • Thomas Hobbes Was Right Anarchy Does Not Work
  • Iraq Study A Long Way From Over
  • US Holds Iraqi Journalist For Five Months

  • Qinetiq Subsidiary's Precision Airdrop System Used By USAF In Afghanistan
  • Raytheon Projectile Scores a Direct Hit Against Moving T-72 Tank
  • BAE Systems Navigation System Passes Extreme G-Force Tests
  • Mighty F-35 Lightning 2 Engine Roars To Life

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement