Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Military Space News .

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Put Tehran On Probation

file photo of the Iranian Parliament.
By Bennett Ramberg
Oustside View Commentator
Los Angeles (UPI) Feb 08, 2006
The Intentional Atomic Energy Agency's reporting of Iran to the Security Council is a striking indictment of Tehran's "failure and breaches of its obligations to comply with the NPT Safeguards Agreement" and an "absence of confidence that [its] nuclear program is exclusively for peaceful purposes."

Tehran's scornful response to the Agency's proposed confidence building measures to "re-establish full and sustained suspension of all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities" leaves the disputants in a deadly embrace begging the question: what do we do now?

Unless the parties come up with a new strategy that allays international suspicions while preserving Iran's "face" and "inalienable" rights under the NPT to develop nuclear energy, including nuclear fuel production for peaceful purposes, current diplomacy offers little wiggle room. As the parties dig in their heels, this leaves military action with all the attendant risks to regional stability and the global oil market.

However, the seeds for resolution may come in Iran's persistent declaration that its nuclear objectives remain peaceful. "Nuclear probation," offers an unexplored option to put this commitment to a final test.

Probation would concede Iran's right to develop a nuclear fuel cycle. But given its history of safeguards violations, Tehran would agree to place resident international inspectors at all atomic sites of concern indefinitely.

But probation would require more, far more. Iran would ratify the Additional Protocol, the IAEA directive requiring parties to open undeclared nuclear sites to snap inspections. No suspicious site would be excluded. It also would expand IAEA access to personnel and procurement documentation, dual-use equipment and military workshops and research and development locations that the Agency demands.

Combating non-compliance, probation would avoid the dithering that now characterizes the international community's response. The probation agreement would lay out the stark consequences endorsed by the Security Council, namely a time table for the imposition of increasingly dramatic punitive measures including economic sanctions, travel restrictions, military blockade and, armed action to destroy suspicious nuclear facilities inventoried by the resident inspectors and other intelligence.

The proposal recognizes the reality that Iran remains determined to get nuclear fuel facilities to preserve nuclear energy independence. Probation allows it to do so while applying teeth to enforce Tehran's nonproliferation vows.

Probation has additional advantages. It does not excuse the clerics for past transgressions. It provides a far more reliable tripwire to discourage a nuclear weapons breakout than IAEA sensors, seals and periodic limited inspections do today.

Rejection of a plan that would meet Tehran's nuclear energy objectives would remove any doubts that Iran is bent on a nuclear weapons program.

Furthermore, probation marks a superior strategy to tried and touted alternatives.

Europe's economic inducements already failed to sway. Likewise, the IAEA's efforts to embarrass Iran through its quarterly public thrashing. Efforts to resurrect Russia's proposal to enrich Iranian processed uranium remains a possibility, but the program butts against Iran's unalterable commitment to a domestic enrichment capacity. Moscow's recent suspension of natural gas deliveries to Ukraine have given the mullahs fodder for preserving energy independence.

To be sure there remains undefined sanctions that the United States will seek in the U.N. Security Council. However, generating the Council's concurrence will be difficult. Neither Russia or China are likely to risk their economic stakes in Iran unless intelligence demonstrates convincingly that Tehran poses a clear and present danger. Other countries also may recoil from the peril that Tehran may reduce oil exports. There also endures the possibility that the clerical regime will follow the North Korean path and bolt from the NPT.

Probation grants Iran one last chance. As a strategy in the IAEA's enforcement quiver, probation adds something equally important: it generates an important precedent setting mechanism that gives the NPT the authority it never has had to assure nonproliferation fidelity. A successful legacy will force parties to associate "inalienable" rights to nuclear technology for peaceful purposes with irrevocable nuclear nonproliferation responsibilities.

Bennett Ramberg served in the State Department during the administration of George H.W. Bush. He is an expert on nuclear terrorism and nuclear weapons proliferation. United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.

Source: United Press International

Related Links

Bush Waives Export Restrictions On Pakistan
Washington (AFP) Feb 08, 2006
US President George W. Bush on Wednesday waived restrictions on exports to Pakistan, saying it would ease the democratic transition in the South Asian nation and help combat terrorism.

  • China Protests US Military Report
  • Rumsfeld Defends US Military Readiness
  • Pentagon Report Singles Out China As Potential Military Rival
  • Pentagon Asks For 439.3Bn Dollar Budget

  • Bush Waives Export Restrictions On Pakistan
  • Suspected drawings of nuclear test site found in Iran
  • Put Tehran On Probation
  • Iranian President Ahmadinejad Angers Russia

  • India Says Latest Nuclear Missile Ready For Launch
  • Iran Secretly Tests New Surface-To-Surface Missile
  • Raytheon-Led Team Tests AIM-9X Missile
  • Lockheed Martin Announces Team For Advanced Precision Kill Weapon System II

  • Congress Gives Alaska $150M Boost With Missile Defense Deployment
  • India Ready To Test The Agni-3
  • Lockheed Martin Delivers Pac-3 Stockpile Reliability Test Missiles
  • Northrop Grumman Receives $225M Contract For ICBM Propulsion Replacement Program

  • Around The World In 80 Hours
  • Lockheed Martin Highlights 5th Gen Fighters And Next Gen Airlift
  • Air Force Announces Quadrennial Defense Review And Budget Highlights
  • Space Transformation Prepares For Air Force Future

  • Philippines To Purchase Unmanned Spy Planes
  • Global Hawk Earns Military Airworthiness Certification
  • USAF Orders Five Predator UAVs
  • Two Production RQ-4A Global Hawks Deploy In Global War On Terrorism

  • UK To Leave Iraq Before Insurgency Ends
  • An Accord On Iraq
  • Insurgents Target Iraqis Over US Troops
  • Outside View: Iraq, Terror War Shocks

  • Lockheed Martin Wins US Army Technology Demonstration Vehicle Contract
  • Infantry Weapon Will Help Deliver A More Precise Capability
  • Force Protection Receives Contract For Specialty Armored Vehicles
  • LockMart Selects Production Site For Advanced Precision Kill Weapon System

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement