Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Military Space News .




Subscribe to our free daily newsletters



The Iraqi Hostage Headache Could Become A Nightmare

Iraqi refugee women wait in the queue at the entrance of the Iraqi Red Crescent's office in the restive city of Samarra, north of Baghdad, 10 February 2007. Iraqi refugees rely on the humanitarian organisation for food and shelter after they were forced to flee their houses to find refuge in safer places due to the sectarian violence in the war-torn country. Photo courtesy AFP.

"Humanitarian agencies have been increasingly hiring private guards. Iraq is no exception. In the lowest estimates, there are about 16,000-18,000 foreign guards in Iraq protecting diplomats, businessmen, journalists, and humanitarian missions."
by Pyotr Goncharov
RIA Novosti Commentator
Moscow (UPI) Feb 15, 2007
The Pentagon has a whole department to supervise stabilization and humanitarian missions in the U.S. troop deployment areas. The primary humanitarian task of a military contingent is to provide support for the supply service - -international charities come next. The department also helps coordinate the work of different humanitarian missions.

This actually amounts to the U.S. official concept, under which combat units receive real time information about the location of humanitarian agencies so that their staff do not fall under random fire.

Joseph J. Collins announced this concept literally on the eve of the U.S. invasion of Iraq. At that time, he was deputy assistant defense secretary. A year later, the situation in Iraq was aggravated by numerous abductions of citizens of the international coalition member-countries, and other states, and by attacks on employees of foreign humanitarian missions, and their murders. The total number of hostages exceeded 40 people.

But in the fall of 2004, Iraq saw a real boom in hostage taking. In different estimates, more than a hundred foreigners had been captured. They came from Japan, South Korea, Russia, the United States, Denmark, the Czech Republic, France, Italy, Britain, and other countries.

Some of them represented different humanitarian missions. Among them were British engineer Kenneth Bigley, Simona Pari and Simona Torretta from the Italian ONG A Bridge to Baghdad, Margaret Hassan from Care International, French journalists, Egyptian telecommunication engineers, Turkish drivers, and many others.

Nobody knows how many people have been taken hostage or killed in the almost four-year-long war in Iraq. In the majority of cases, unknown extremist groups claimed responsibility, demanding foreign troop withdrawal from Iraq. The Sunni clergy have denounced these actions (there is a firm belief that extremists are mostly Sunni).

What happened in 2006? The U.S. Congress-established Baker-Hamilton Study Group believes that the situation in Iraq is getting worse and is bordering on a humanitarian disaster, that Bush's policy does not work. It is hard to say whether humanitarian missions are safer or not.

Strange as it may seem, many experts believe that the situation with humanitarian missions is not as bad as it was in 2004. The statement by the Sunni clergy has probably had its effect; the removal of al-Qaida's second-in-command Ayman al-Zawahiri could also have been a contributing factor.

Be that as it may, but we are interested in something else, notably, Washington's view on its responsibility for humanitarian missions. For all intents and purposes, the United States wants humanitarian agencies to take care of their safety themselves - any occupation troops have the same approach. There are grounds for this. The United Nations alone has sent more than 100,000 employees of humanitarian missions to hot spots.

This is a noble but dangerous cause. Almost 30 U.N. volunteers lost their lives in Afghanistan, which is considered one of the safest places for these agencies. Yet, armed protection of humanitarian agencies by occupational (or counterterrorist, as in Afghanistan) forces will undermine the very idea of a mission's "absolute neutrality" in an armed conflict. The status of humanitarian missions commits them to render aid to all strata of the population, including opponents of the regime.

It would be ideal if the population could protect a humanitarian mission. This is the underlying idea of its work. But in recent times, humanitarian agencies have been increasingly hiring private guards. Iraq is no exception. In the lowest estimates, there are about 16,000-18,000 foreign guards in Iraq protecting diplomats, businessmen, journalists, and humanitarian missions.

It is quite possible to use their services. But it is much better to have one's own expert who speaks the local language, knows the country and its traditions, has contacts, and is good at establishing them. Such an expert would determine the level of danger, and choose the best way of protecting a mission. Since times immemorial, a humanitarian mission has been a very delicate matter.

(Pyotr Goncharov is a political commentator for the RIA Novosti news agency. This article is reprinted by permission of RIA Novosti. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of the editorial board.)

Source: RIA Novosti

Email This Article

Related Links
Iraq: The first technology war of the 21st century

US Says Marine Helicopter Was Shot Down
Baghdad (AFP) Feb 14, 2007
A US Marine transport helicopter that crashed a week ago was shot down, the military said Wednesday, after an earlier report had suggested mechanical failure. It was the seventh US helicopter, including two private aircraft, to go down in a three week-span. Seven people died in the crash on February 7, while 27 have been killed in all six crashes.







  • The Bear Roars From The East
  • Putin Takes A Tour Of The Mideast
  • China Flexes Its Muscle To Help Defuse North Korean Nuclear Crisis
  • Absence Of US-China Military Dialogue Triggers Worries In US

  • Russia May Unilaterally Quit INF Treaty
  • China Wants Quick Work On North Korea Deal
  • Too Early To Consider Lifting North Korea Sanctions
  • Saudi Looking Into Nuclear Energy Offers

  • Putin Denies Passing Missile Technology To Iran
  • Raytheon And BAE Test Fire DDG 1000 MK57 Vertical Launching System
  • India Test-Fires Supersonic Cruise Missile
  • Israeli Media Says Syria Has Tested Scud

  • Why Russia Fears Ballistic Missile Defense
  • US Missile Plans For Europe
  • Polish Prime Minister Backs US Missile Shield As Russians Outline Consequences
  • Russia Not Worried About US Missile Shield

  • Can UABC Take Russian Aircraft-Makers Out Of Spin
  • Superjet To Be Tested For Strength
  • Anger As Britons Face Air Tax Hike
  • Bats In Flight Reveal Unexpected Aerodynamics

  • UAV Tested For US Border Security
  • Iran Claims New Stealth Drone That Can Attack US Gulf Fleet
  • Boeing ScanEagle Team Achieves Compliance With NATO UAV Interoperability Standard
  • US Navy Buys Two Northrop Grumman Fire Scouts To Refine Concept Of Operations

  • The Iraqi Hostage Headache Could Become A Nightmare
  • US Says Marine Helicopter Was Shot Down
  • Iraq Army Deploying On Time
  • One Size Does Not Fit All In Iraq

  • Future Combat Systems Restructuring A Balancing Act
  • India's Showcase Chopper Crashes Ahead Of Airshow
  • Language Learning Via Video Gaming
  • Future Combat Systems Completes Experiment and Soldier-testing Of Key Technologies

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement