. Military Space News .
Nuke-Free North Korea A Fantasy Despite Six-Nation Talk Hype
File photo of a North Korea nuclear pride rally. Photo courtesy AFP.
File photo of a North Korea nuclear pride rally. Photo courtesy AFP.
by Karl Malakunas
Beijing (AFP) Dec 17, 2006
North Korea returns to six-nation talks on its nuclear program Monday following a 13-month break amid high hopes it may agree to give up its atomic ambitions, but analysts say this is a fantasy. The United States, desperate for a rare foreign policy victory, has said ahead of the much-anticipated resumption of the negotiations in Beijing that it is aiming for North Korea to abandon its nuclear program within two years.

US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice stated the goal last week amid reports the United States would try to tempt North Korea with security guarantees, possible lifting of sanctions and other carrots.

The incentives and what North Korea must do in return for them will be the main focus of the new round of six-nation talks -- involving the two Koreas, the United States, host China, Japan and Russia -- which first began in 2003.

But a wide range of analysts and seasoned North Korea watchers contacted by AFP were unanimous in their assessment that Kim Jong-Il had no intention of surrendering the nuclear program his nation had spent decades developing.

"North Korea giving up its nuclear weapons will never happen," said John Feffer, the global affairs director at the US-based International Relations Center.

"Now that North Korea has the nuclear bargaining chip, it is never going to give it up. And the United States is not in a position to change North Korea's position."

When North Korea returns to the negotiating table, it will be 63 days since it conducted its first ever nuclear test on October 9.

The test triggered widespread international condemnation -- including from closest ally and neighbor China -- and led to United Nations sanctions against Kim's regime.

A popular view put forward by the United States is that the global pressure forced North Korea to return to the talks, after it boycotted them for 13 months in protest at US financial sanctions imposed for money laundering.

But Scott Bruce, the program officer at the Nautilus Institute in Berkeley, which specializes in North Korean nuclear issues, said the nation had come back to the talks on its own terms.

"North Korea wants to make an appearance at the talks as a normal, nuclear weapons state and announce its perceived equality to the US," Bruce said.

He said North Korea was using the talks to buy itself more time to develop its nuclear program.

"Every day that passes is one more day until (US President) George Bush leaves office and one more day that the DPRK (North Korea) gets to continue to reprocess plutonium and build its nuclear arsenal," he said.

Zhang Liangui, a professor with one of China's schools for its Communist Party elite, wrote recently that reversing North Korea's nuclear status was possible, but extremely unlikely.

"The nuclear test conducted by... North Korea reveals that government leaders long ago made a decision to develop and possess nuclear weapons," Zhang wrote in China Security, a journal of the US-based World Security Institute.

"Having made such a commitment, it is unlikely that they will give them up -- not for anything."

One way that North Korea could be swayed into giving up its nuclear weapons was if China and South Korea withdrew their economic support that keeps the desperately poor nation running.

But the two nations have made clear they are not prepared to do that for a range of reasons, high among them the fear of triggering regime change.

Amid such sentiments, analysts scoffed at the US goal of disarming North Korea in two years, saying the Bush administration knew this was impossible but dare not admit it because of so many other foreign policy failures.

Feffer, of the International Relations Center, said continuing the talks allowed Washington to give the appearance of hope to the US electorate on North Korea.

"With Iraq falling apart, the Taliban rising in Afghanistan and Iran thumbing its nose at Washington, the Bush administration would like to be able to say, before the next elections, that it handled at least one foreign policy crisis adequately," he said.

earlier related report
Nation that Can Not Feed Itself Puts Nuclear Weapons First
Seoul (AFP) Dec 15 - North Korea, a reclusive Stalinist nation that cannot feed its people or power many of its factories, has striven for decades to develop nuclear weapons. The country whose ideology is "juche", or self-reliance, has depended on food aid for much of the past decade to feed many of its 23 million people. Hundreds of people died in a famine that started in 1995 and went on for years.

Refugee aid group Helping Hands Korea has warned that North Koreans may again face famine this winter as disenchanted international donors cut back on aid after missile tests in July and a nuclear test on October 9.

South Korea suspended regular rice and fertiliser aid shipments after the missile tests and continued the suspension after the nuclear detonation.

Officially the North, which since its creation in 1948 has maintained a policy of unrelenting hostility to Washington, blames US threats to attack it and weaken it through sanctions for its test.

But its policy of Songun, or "army first", may also have played a large part. The slogan first appeared around August 1998 when the North alarmed Japan by launching a long-range missile over the country.

"It has maintained this rhetoric, prompting some to speculate that internal divisions led (leader) Kim Jong-Il to try to solidify his position in the eyes of his million-man army," the International Crisis Group wrote in a recent report.

Kim may also have used the nuclear test to rally public support before what is expected to be a hard winter. The "Dear Leader" is widely believed to be less popular than his father and founding president Kim Il-Sung -- the Great Leader.

Kim Il-Sung died in 1994 after fostering a personality cult bordering on idolatry, but officially remains president for eternity inside his mausoleum.

The younger Kim took over leadership of the ruling party in 1997 amid acute economic difficulties.

The economy, already burdened by the cost of the world's fourth largest military force, shrank in 1997 for the eighth successive year since the collapse of communism in former benefactor the Soviet Union.

The younger Kim opened the reclusive state to some degree, including a landmark summit with South Korea in 2000.

Two years later the regime introduced limited reforms to the centralised command economy, allowing some flexibility in state-set prices and granting incentives to workplaces and workers.

But in October 2005 it banned private grain sales and announced a return to centralised food rationing.

At the end of 2005 the North suspended the World Food Programme's 10-year emergency programme and severely curtailed its activities. Food aid now comes mainly from China and South Korea and energy from China.

Outside Pyongyang, where the elite and other privileged classes largely live, life remains harsh. A US State Department report said the nation "continues to suffer chronic food shortages and malnutrition."

The North's rights record is also widely condemned.

A United Nations panel last month cited "torture, public executions, extrajudicial and arbitrary detention, the absence of due process and the rule of law, the imposition of the death penalty for political reasons, the existence of a large number of prison camps and the extensive use of forced labor".

Source: Agence France-Presse

Related Links
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com

Japan Does Not See North Korea As A Nuclear Power Foreign Minister
Tokyo (AFP) Dec 17, 2006
Japan's Foreign Minister Taro Aso reiterated Sunday that Japan does not consider North Korea a nuclear power as envoys gather in Beijing for six-nation talks after a hiatus of more than a year. Asked by reporters if Japan recognizes the North as a nuclear power, Aso said, "No, it doesn't."







  • Japan Creates Defense Ministry For First Time Since 1945
  • 100 Years Of Grandpa Brezhnev
  • Watching America
  • Shock And Awe About-Face

  • Japan Does Not See North Korea As A Nuclear Power Foreign Minister
  • Russia To Get New Mobile ICBMs
  • Nuke-Free North Korea A Fantasy Despite Six-Nation Talk Hype
  • US Tells North Korea To Get Serious About Denuclearization

  • LockMart-Built Trident II D5 Launched In Two-Missile US Navy Test
  • LockMart Announces Firing Of Hellfire II Missile During French Evaluation
  • Raytheon Awarded Contract For Missile Launcher Production
  • Pakistan Test Fires Nuclear-Capable Missile

  • BMD Focus: Collision course with Russia
  • Raytheon Ships Second Ballistic Missile Defense System Radar
  • Russian Military Chief Warns Of US Anti-Missile Shield Impact
  • Pakistan Tests Nuclear-Capable Ballistic Missile

  • Aerospace Manufacturers Meeting The Technology Challenge Of Climate Change
  • German Govt Wants To Cap Airline Carbon Dioxide Emissions
  • Boeing Business Jets Delivers Its 100th Green Airplane
  • A380 Wraps Up Technical Route Proving After a Final Trip Over Both Poles

  • Boeing Australia To Provide Australia Its First Tactical UAV
  • Boeing, U.S. Air Force Demonstrate UAV Automated Aerial Refueling Capability
  • Lockheed Martin Tests New Centralized Controller For Unmanned Air And Systems
  • Cyber Defense's CyberBug UAV Participates In NATO Exercises

  • US Military Too Strained For Iraq Troop Increase: Colin Powell
  • The Complext Challenge Facing Bush In Iraq
  • The Myth Of Sending More Troops
  • ISG Report Irks Iraqi President

  • Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II Stealth Fighter Completes First Flight
  • US DoD And United Kingdom Sign Next Stage Joint Strike Fighter Agreement
  • The IED Boomerang Effect
  • Lockheed Martin F-35 Completes First Ground Taxi Test

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement