. Military Space News .
Security improvements alone not enough to win in Iraq: Pentagon

by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Sept 17, 2007
The Pentagon reported to Congress Monday that political progress in Iraq remains stalled despite a surge in US forces, and warned that improvements in security were not enough to win the war. The quarterly report to Congress on stability and security in Iraq said the surge had led to improvements in security, including a drop in sectarian killing and civilian casualties and a downward trend in attacks.

"Improved security and stability is not enough to win the counterinsurgency," the report said. "Political progress must also be achieved to reinforce and complement progress in securing the Iraqi population."

"There has been little national-level political progress in passing key legislation and implementing government reform," it said.

"Efforts within Iraq's political process to seek consensus remain complicated by continued sectarian divisions and violence that exacerbates those divisions," it said.

The report said the most promising political developments were at the local level, where the US military is pursuing a so-called "bottom up" approach to reconciliation with Sunni insurgents disenchanted with Al-Qaeda.

The findings generally tracked with presentations to Congress last week by General David Petraeus, who proposed a gradual drawdown of US surge forces by July 2008 on the strength of the improved security.

An additional 30,000 US troops were deployed to Iraq starting in February to try to halt a slide toward civil war and give Iraqi political leaders "breathing space" to achieve national reconciliation.

Currently 169,000 US troops are in Iraq.

"As a result of these efforts, there are improvements in measures of security; for example, sectarian killings and civilian casualties have decreased," the report said.

There has been "some improvement" in Iraqis ability to go about their daily life, it said.

"Overall there continues to be a downward trend in total attack incidents with eight of the past 11 weeks since June 15, 2007 showing decreases down to August 2006 levels," it said.

It said the surge has started to create conditions that will allow the government to make reforms and pursue reconciliation initiatives.

But key pieces of legislation aimed at forging reconciliation -- such as a Hydrocarbons Law governing the sharing of oil revenues, and progress on the status of the disputed northern city of Kirkuk -- "will probably remain stalled in the near term," it said.

"Prospects for success in the near term hinge upon the return of key political blocs to the Maliki government," the report said.

The government of Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki faced a fresh crisis Monday with the withdrawal of followers of Shiite cleric Moqtada Sadr from the main Shiite bloc in parliament.

Sunni ministers bolted from the Maliki government in August, leaving Maliki with a weakened coalition of Shiite and Kurds.

related report
US could make 'further withdrawals': Iraqi FM
Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari said Monday he was not surprised that some American troops were being pulled out of Iraq next year and mentioned the possibility of further withdrawals.

In a speech on Thursday, US President George W. Bush said that the size of the US force in Iraq would decrease by about 21,500 combat troops by mid-2008, with the first 5,700 soldiers leaving Iraq in December. Most of those soldiers had been scheduled to rotate back to the United States at that time.

"The declaration that there will be a withdrawal of a number of US troops from Iraq has not come as a major surprise to us," Zebari said after meeting his Czech counterpart Karl Schwarzenberg in Prague.

"In fact that was expected in view of the fierce political debate and of domestic pressure and also due to the (...) military situation on the ground.

"There could be some further withdrawal also, but we have been assured by the US administration that the commitment would remain," he added.

Currently 169,000 US troops are in Iraq, up from 130,000 before Bush announced a "surge" of US forces in January.

Defense Secretary Robert Gates played down Monday his own suggestion before the weekend that US forces in Iraq could be cut to about 100,000 by the end of 2008.

"What I said was I hoped the conditions would improve in Iraq to the extent that not only could we complete the drawdowns that General (David) Petraeus would like to make, but we would continue thereafter," Gates said on Fox News.

"So everything depends on the conditions on the ground."

Zebari said he hoped that as American troops left, the Iraqi security forces would be able to step up to the plate.

"On the other hand we are considering some long term arrangement between Iraq, the United States and other countries for some joint security partnership that would be reassuring to us," he added.

Source: Agence France-Presse
Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Iraq: The first technology war of the 21st century



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


US military likely to be in Iraq for years after drawdown
Washington (AFP) Sept 14, 2007
The US military will be tied down in Iraq with 100,000 troops at least through the presidency of George W. Bush, and a modest size residual force will be there for years to come.







  • Outside View: Life after START
  • Analysis: Strategic strike capability
  • Putin sends legislation on key arms control treaty to parliament
  • Russia draws 'red line' on Kosovo, US missile defence

  • US believes NKorea talks will take place next week
  • US pledges to reduce plutonium weapons stockpiles
  • NKorea bought materials used to build centrifuges: report
  • 'War' talk heightens Iran nuclear dispute

  • Russia to deploy Iskander missiles in three years: official
  • B-52 carried nuclear armed cruise missiles by mistake: US
  • Bulava Missile Not Ready For Mass Production
  • US to look into North Korea's missile threat

  • US military team set to inspect Russian radar in Azerbaijan
  • Russia-US talks on missile shield made no progress: Moscow
  • Outside View: Upgrading Gabala
  • Lockheed Martin Achieves Key Integration Milestone On First-Of-Its-Kind Missile Warning Satellite

  • NCAR Teams With United Airlines To Pinpoint Turbulence In Clouds: Research Can Help Reduce Delays, Injuries, Costs
  • KC-30 Tanker's General Electric Power Plant Completes One Million Takeoff And Landing Cycles
  • Skyray 48 Takes Flight
  • Asia's largest airshow to ride on China's wings

  • Navy MQ-8B Fire Scout Gets a Lift From Marine Corps KC-130T Hercules
  • QinetiQ's Zephyr UAV Exceeds Official World Record For Longest Duration Unmanned Flight
  • Thompson Files: Air Force drones are best
  • New LITENING Targeting System Demonstrated During USJFC's Bold Quest Exercise

  • Security improvements alone not enough to win in Iraq: Pentagon
  • US military likely to be in Iraq for years after drawdown
  • Interview: Governor of Kirkuk province
  • Bush to announce plans for Iraq troop levels

  • Lockheed Martin Unveils New Guidance Kit For 70MM Rockets
  • Outside View: Vacuum-bomb warning
  • Raytheon Awarded 5 Million Dollar Rapid Aerostat Initial Deployment Contract Option
  • Defense Focus: Cinderella service

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement