. Military Space News .

Europe and NATO weakened despite Libya victory
by Staff Writers
Brussels (AFP) Aug 24, 2011

France and Britain proved their military ability in the absence of US leadership in Libya but the European Union and NATO emerged paradoxically weakened, analysts said.

Many had warned them against getting bogged down in an Iraq-style quagmire in Libya but after six months, both Paris and London this week felt vindicated when the operation they led helped rebels topple Moamer Kadhafi's regime.

The intervention mandated by the United Nations and carried out under NATO command "is a success because two major nations took their responsibilities," French Defence Minister Gerard Longuet said earlier this week.

The Libya raids were a watershed because they marked a rare case of the United States shunning the leadership role in a large Western military intervention, leaving France and Britain to fill the vacuum.

"The Brits and the French can rightly claim to have delivered in spite of America taking the backseat," Francois Heisbourg, from the Paris-based Foundation for Strategic Research, said.

But Andre Dumoulin, from the Multidisciplinary Network for Strategic Studies, argued that Washington's role in the aerial bombing campaign that annihilated Kadhafi's military infrastructure was secondary only on paper.

"The Americans did mobilise considerable means when it was required," the analyst said.

He cited cruise missiles early on in the bombing to destroy Libya's anti-aircraft defences, reconnaissance capabilities and electronic warfare, as well as surveillance work during the final Tripoli battle.

Kadhafi is still at large and loyalists still in control of some towns but Libya's Western-backed National Transitional Council is already promising elections and talking about reconstruction.

With the war not yet fully won, analysts argued that the EU and NATO already had some rebuilding of their own to do in the aftermath of an operation launched without clear support from all member states.

"More than half of the 28 NATO member states were against this war," Heisbourg said.

In the Atlantic alliance, Germany was staunchly opposed to the intervention and other countries such as Poland refused to contribute despite repeated calls while Turkey only agreed to a minimal role.

"There is an obvious political weakening of NATO," Heisbourg said.

"From March 31, NATO played host to the operational command centre but it never controlled policy and strategy," he added.

Another collateral victim of French-British leadership was the ever-recurring issue of a joint European Defence project.

"Europe as a political and strategic force was completely absent, that is the sad truth," said a European diplomat.

In the longer term, analysts voiced doubt that a split NATO leadership, with the Europeans taking the lead on wars closer to their patch and the US on faraway operations, was sustainable.

Heisbourg argued that Washington's shrinking defence budget was one of the reasons for its limited involvement in Libya.

That leaves Europeans less available for other theatres such as Afghanistan and will also force them to invest in certain types of equipment for which they usually relied on Washington.

"We have a structural problem because European states also have economic problems, don't have much spending power and tend to turn to the United States," Dumoulin said.

Related Links
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com

Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
Buy Advertising Editorial Enquiries

China state news agency accuses US of 'interfering'
Beijing (AFP) Aug 25, 2011 - China's state-run news agency on Thursday accused the United States of "interfering" after a Pentagon report warned that the Asian power's military was increasingly focused on naval power.

Xinhua said the annual Pentagon report to US Congress had drawn protest in the past over its "interfering nature" and "distortion of facts", although it welcomed recent improvements in military relations between the two powers.

"The 94-page report, as usual, interferes with the internal issue of China by making wilful comments on the situation across Taiwan Straits," Xinhua said.

China considers Taiwan, where the mainland's defeated nationalists fled in 1949, to be a province awaiting reunification, by force if necessary.

The Pentagon report released on Wednesday renewed US warnings that China was extending its military edge over Taiwan, citing better artillery that could strike targets within or even across the Taiwan Strait.

Xinhua also accused the Pentagon of "overlooking the country's peaceful defence policy" in its report, which said China's military was investing in high-tech weaponry that would extend its reach in the Pacific and beyond.

The weapons buildup comes as the Asian economic giant places a growing emphasis on securing strategic shipping lanes and mineral-rich areas in the South China Sea.

"The Pentagon report, submitted to the Congress by the Pentagon annually pursuant to a US law since 2000, has drawn protest from China over its interfering nature, distortion of facts and baseless speculations," the Xinhua report said.

"This year's report, however, said the United States recognises China's contributions that support a safe and secure global environment."

The dispute over Taiwan, including US arms sales to Taipei, has remained a stumbling block to Washington's attempts at promoting a security dialogue with the Chinese military.

However, Xinhua said relations between the US and Chinese militaries had improved over the past year.

It cited a visit to China last month by US Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Mike Mullen, America's top military official. Mullen's Chinese counterpart Chen Bingde visited the United States last year.

. Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Biden to meet China's leader-in-waiting
Beijing (AFP) Aug 18, 2011
US Vice President Joe Biden meets the man widely expected to become China's next leader on Thursday, as he begins official talks in Beijing under a cloud of criticism over the US debt crisis. Biden flew into the Chinese capital on Wednesday, starting a five-day trip that will see him try to revive the image of the United States after a historic debt downgrade, and put up a robust defence of ... read more

Raytheon Teams with Rafael to Market Iron Dome Weapon System

Airborne Infrared Sensor Cued In ABM Test With The Integrated Sensor Manager

Moscow warns NATO against extending missile shield

US destroys missile over Pacific in test

Russia 'surprised' by Iran's legal complaint over S-300

Ahmadinejad unveils new marine missile, torpedo

Taiwan to develop precision-guided missile

LockMart Demos Rocket Motor Survivability In Fixed-Wing Flight Environments

Canadian drone helped rebels in Libya

US drone attack kills four militants in Pakistan: officials

Raytheon Unmanned Aircraft Systems Open Architecture Could Yield Cost Savings

Boeing Demonstrates Swarm Reconnaissance with Unmanned Aircraft

"Network in A Box" Allows Military Vehicles To Be Used For Multiple Missions

Space Command retires workhorse satellite

Raytheon Develops Miniature Antenna To Extend Millimeter Wave Friendly ID Technology

China launches another experimental satellite

Chile opts for refurbished U.S. howitzers

Raytheon Approach to DARPA Project Applicable For All Military Services

Northrop Grumman Wins Mission Command Training Contract

Revolutionary material dramatically increases explosive force of weapons

Boeing Delivers 3 More F-15K Slam Eagles to the Republic of Korea

China calls US report on its military 'groundless'

U.K. defense supply chain threatened

Britain orders 14 Boeing Chinooks in 1bn deal

China state news agency accuses US of 'interfering'

Europe and NATO weakened despite Libya victory

China accuses US of 'exaggerating' military threat

Biden to meet China's leader-in-waiting

Boeing and BAE Systems to Develop Integrated Directed Energy Weapon for US Navy

System Integration of High Energy Laser Technology Demonstrator Completed

Raytheon Acquires Directed Energy Capabilities of Ktech Corporation

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily Express :: SpaceWar Express :: TerraDaily Express :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2011 - Space Media Network. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement