Washington (UPI) Mar 30, 2011
Wars too often are created by illusions and delusions. This is what is happening in Libya.
It is an illusion to believe that if Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi clings to power, the credibility and authority of the United Nations, Arab League, NATO, United States and other states comprising the opposing coalition won't be dealt a severe blow with accruing consequences.
But, it is a delusion to think that if the rebels don't succeed in ridding Libya of this desert rat, there is no possibility of an outside ground assault to finish job.
The excruciating dilemma is that to limit the damage caused by the first illusion of Gadhafi holding on, reversing the delusion that no alternative exists leads to a course of action likely to prove unacceptable. Either way, the news is very bad.
As a result, we could be stuck in Libya and in a larger sense with an Arab Spring that could metastasize into an Arab winter of discontent.
We have agonized over what to do about Libya. The Arab League surprisingly sought a no-fly zone over Libya to protect civilians. Despite five abstentions, the United Nations followed suit with U.N. Security Council Resolution 1973 authorizing "all necessary means" short of occupation to protect innocent civilians.
Then NATO, in its own lurching way, pressured by the United States and United Kingdom, agreed to assume command of all military operations that include sustaining a no-fly zone, airstrikes to protect (and aid) the rebels and an arms embargo.
The demand that Gadhafi must go leads to an inescapable conclusion. Like it or not -- and very few will like it -- ground forces may be necessary to remove Gadhafi if he doesn't leave by other means or if the rebels fail to dislodge him. Stalemate is to Gadhafi's advantage.
At this point, the use of outside ground forces is thinking about the unthinkable. Who would have the capacity and the stomach to supply the forces?
Beyond that very tricky matter, no one has any idea of what a replacement government would look like, how that transition could be made and for how long outside countries are prepared to invest time and money to ensure stability in that oil rich land.
And, perhaps we unsuspectingly delude ourselves by calling the rebels "democratic forces."
U.S. President Barack Obama tried to square these circles in his address Monday night. Sadly, the president had no running room. He didn't wish to antagonize Arabs and Muslims further by calling for a third U.S. intervention into those worlds.
For the moment, explicit recognition of the need to use force to expel or remove Gadhafi is something the administration will defer like the plague until it sees whether the rebel forces are capable of achieving that end state with minimal outside help.
The tragedy is that we and the coalition face a potential quagmire. And the options are not favorable.
First, the rebels could succeed in throwing Gadhafi out one way or another. Providing arms and air attacks could be part of this option best conducted with Arab or Muslim help from outside Libya. For a betting person, this is a "Hail Mary" option.
Second, a standoff or partition of Libya with Gadhafi in control in the west and the rebels in the east could follow.
Tightening Obama's noose, Gadhafi would face a strategy of attrition and death by a thousand cuts. Significantly, he would still be in power and this could last for an extended period. This option makes hollow our threats and credibility and makes Gadhafi at least the de facto winner.
Finally, there is a Noriega option. In December 1989, U.S. President George H.W. Bush sent U.S. forces into Panama to capture President Manuel Noriega. A similar operation could be mounted to end Gadhafi's rule.
The risks are breathtaking. The prospect of bloody battles and massive casualties cannot be excluded. Reprisals against such an attack from terror groups would be likely.
A political backlash, and not merely from the Arab world, as Security Council Resolution 1973 precludes occupation would be severe. And finding the forces and willing partners to intervene may be Missions: Impossible.
Here, illusion collides with delusion. Whether the United Nations, Arab League and other organizations realized it or not, a no-fly zone would ultimately lead to this juncture. To succeed, Gadhafi must go. If the rebels are unable to achieve that goal, someone else must. This is the inevitable consequence of the decision to impose a no-fly zone and the illusion it would work.
Perhaps the leaking of such plans will force Gadhafi to quit. But don't count on it. Then, if all else fails, the illusion will leave a single unpalatable and risk-laden alternative -- direct intervention on the ground -- what some will call the ultimate delusion.
(Harlan Ullman is chairman of the Killowen Group, which advises leaders of government and business, and senior adviser at Washington's Atlantic Council.)
(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
China's Hu warns Sarkozy on Libya strikes
Beijing (AFP) March 30, 2011
Coalition military strikes on Libya could violate the "intention" of the UN resolution if civilians suffer, Chinese President Hu Jintao on Wednesday told visiting French leader Nicolas Sarkozy. The tough talk from Hu came during a meeting at the start of Sarkozy's mini-tour of Asia, which will include a G20 meeting on global monetary reform and a stop in disaster-struck Japan. Britain, F ... read more
Israel to deploy four more 'Iron Dome' anti-rocket defences|
LockMart Awarded THAAD Production Contract
Israeli port city gets Iron Dome anti-rocket system
LockMart Huntsville Integrated Test Center To Support For Missile Defense
MDA Awards Raytheon Contract For New SM-3 Block IB
Multipurpose HELLFIRE II 'Romeo' Strikes Target
Rocket slams into Israel city as Gaza violence spirals
Taiwan missile test flops again
AeroVironment Global Observer Experiences Mishap During Extended Duration Flight Testing
Euro Hawk Undergoes Testing At Edwards AFB
Northrop Grumman Ships First Broad Area Maritime Surveillance Fuselage
Northrop Grumman Submits Final Proposal For NATO Alliance Ground Surveillance
Global Military Communications Market In 2010
Raytheon BBN Technologies To Protect Internet Comms For Military Abroad
Gilat Announces New Military Modem For Robust Tactical Satcom-On-The-Move
Advanced Emulation Accelerates Deployment Of Military Network Technologies
LockMart Rolls Out First Special Operations MC-130J Combat Shadow II
Picatinny Fields First Precision-Guided Mortars To Troops In Afghanistan
PEO Ammo Picks Up 155mm Lightweight Howitzer Program
S. American security firms heavily armed
Gurkas in first wave of British military job cuts
China's industry working with military
US freezes arms shipments to Lebanon: report
Australian Defense Industry Expected To Grow
Commentary: Celebrity diplomacy
ASEAN disunity weakening China relations
Outside View: Illusions, delusions of war
Tsunami washes away hopes for Japan's young
Scientists Build World's First Anti-Laser
Yale scientists build 'anti-laser'
'Air laser' could find bombs at a distance
ONR Achieves Milestone In Free Electron Laser Program
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|