Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Military Space News .

Subscribe free to our newsletters via your

The Viability Of The Russian ICBM Stockpile

It was emphasized that it would take only $100,000 to convert the RS-20, developed at the Ukrainian Yuzhnoye design bureau, into a first-class launch vehicle.
by Andrei Kislyakov
UPI Outside View Commentator
Moscow (UPI) Jul 28, 2006
Anything more sophisticated than a steel ingot is liable to break. This maxim, of course, applies to rockets. Even so, the setback suffered on the night of July 26 by a Russian RS-20 Voyevoda (SS-18 Satan) intercontinental ballistic missile converted into a Dnepr launch vehicle makes one question the wisdom of converting ICBMs, at least today.

The rocket, launched at midnight, had not flown more than two minutes when the first-stage engine cut out and the vehicle crashed about 190 kilometers (120 miles) from the Baikonur space center, destroying 18 small satellites developed by students from Russia, the United States and Italy, and specialists from Belarus and Colombia.

In addition to representatives of university student centers, President Alexander Lukashenko of Belarus and Russian Space Center head Anatoly Perminov watched the launch.

The idea of converting strategic missiles became a reality in 1993 when the Treaty on Further Reduction and Limitation of Strategic Offensive Arms (or START-II) was signed, obliging Russia to remove most of its ground-based missiles from operational status, notably RS-20s, ICBMs with unique combat characteristics.

The scheme seemed simple and logical. Instead of a costly disposal program, inevitably involving American money, the junk could be scrapped by simply "firing" the missiles, with a triple benefit: complying with the treaty, boosting the country's prestige, and making money on commercial launches. It was emphasized that it would take only $100,000 to convert the RS-20, developed at the Ukrainian Yuzhnoye design bureau, into a first-class launch vehicle.

But the fast and easy wizardry seen in Charles Perrault's Cinderella does not, by definition, work with rockets. The first premise is that any time something is remade to conform to new standards and objectives, while at the same time maintaining high quality, it is always more costly than developing and manufacturing a new prototype. This is a time-tested rule that applies to all human endeavors. Any talk of high quality or reliability in the Dnepr case at a price of only $100,000 was a lot of hot air. It is not yet time to go into technical details except perhaps by making one general remark.

However fantastic a product's safety, dependability or longevity, a quarter-century of operational duty cannot pass without leaving its impact. A special commission will hopefully describe the particulars of the accident.

This raises another question: Why should we have such a launch vehicle? As the Russian Space Agency boldly claims, the Dnepr is capable of placing a payload of up to 3.7 tons in low orbits of 300 to 900 kilometers (186 to 560 miles).

In passing it may be observed that a multiple firing of the third-stage engine is required to put spacecraft into an orbit of 700 to 1,200 kilometers (435 to 745 miles). Despite my efforts, I could find no mention of the required refurbishment of the Satan's third stage.

But let us return to our "why." Indeed, in the mid-1990s, with mobile communications making whirlwind progress, specialists in Europe and America justly believed that a very large number of low-orbit satellites would be needed covering a considerable area. So a niche for conversion rockets existed, but fate decreed otherwise. Practically all programs using low-orbit satellites for mobile purposes were scrapped in favor of ground facilities.

However, any day now we will certainly see other ambitious programs for compact-sized craft. But it is cheaper and more reliable to develop a new launch vehicle, particularly since Russia is a leader in this field.

At the moment, though, low-orbit commercial launches fetch low profits. General interest focuses on the geostationary orbit (36,000 kilometers, or 22,370 miles) where large space communications systems can be placed. This is why the Khrunichev center and NPOmash have come up with a commercial proposal to use another converted missile, the RS-18 Rokot (SS-19 Stiletto), to place small payloads into a stationary orbit.

Specialists say such satellites will perform as well as large ones. But most significantly of all, the two centers are offering a package service. It includes manufacturing a satellite with an original inert-gas-burning propulsion unit, converting an army missile into a launch vehicle, and orbiting the satellite -- operations a customer today can obtain only from different companies, often in different countries. The promoters of the idea also intend to afford the client the use of both ground-control facilities and equipment for receiving, processing and sending information to the end user. Now there's a real conversion for you.

(Andrei Kislyakov is a political commentator for RIA Novosti.)

(United Press International's "Outside View" commentaries are written by outside contributors who specialize in a variety of important issues. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of United Press International. In the interests of creating an open forum, original submissions are invited.)

Source: United Press International

Related Links

US Ready To Isolate North Korea Over Nuclear Weapons
Baguio, Philippines (UPI) Jul 30, 2006
The United States is ready to isolate North Korea internationally over its nuclear weapons program, the top US State Department envoy on the country said Sunday. Assistant Secretary of State Christopher Hill said the North Koreans "seem to like to isolate themselves."

  • Is China A Military Threat To The United States
  • China blasts Security Council silence over UN deaths in Lebanon
  • Japan hails "toilet diplomacy" with China
  • American Uberpower Makes For Grim Lonely Times

  • US Ready To Isolate North Korea Over Nuclear Weapons
  • Pakistan Says New Nuclear Reactor Safe In Our Hands
  • Iran Hangs On Mideast Outcome
  • The Viability Of The Russian ICBM Stockpile

  • North Korean Long-Range Missile Ended In Failure Says Japanese Report
  • Indian Army To Get World's First Supersonic Cruise Missiles
  • JAVELIN Anti-tank Missile Systems Sale To Bahrain
  • India tests surface-to-air missile

  • Taiwan Successfully Test Fires Patriot Missile Defense System
  • Missile Defense Element Successfully Flight Tested
  • LockMart Awards Aegis Data Recording Systems Contract To VMETRO
  • Experts Debate Space-Based Missile Defense Assets

  • Boeing Puts Aircraft Market At 2.6 Trillion Dollars
  • Innovative Solutions Make Transportation Systems Safer Secure and Efficient
  • Joint Strike Fighter Is Not Flawed Finds Australian Government
  • Globemaster Airdrops Falcon Small Launch Vehicle

  • Unmanned Aerial System A Step Closer
  • Mediaware Awarded Contract For North West Shelf UAV Trial
  • Schilling Robotics Sells State-of-the-Art Remotely Operated Vehicle
  • Marines Eye Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Capabilities

  • Casualties In Iraq Climb Again
  • US, Iraqi troops to go to Baghdad 'in fairly good numbers': Rumsfeld
  • Iraqi Forces One Spot Of Good News Says Top General
  • The Shiite Bloody Saturday Leaves Baghdad Reeling

  • TIAX To Develop Skin Cream To Protect Soldiers From Chemical Warfare Agents
  • OSI Geospatial Teams With L-3 Communications Marine Systems
  • New Long-Range Bomber On Horizon For 2018
  • Second Generation Power System For US Military

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement